Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - ‘Death of democracy’: CNRP dissolved by Supreme Court ruling

‘Death of democracy’:
CNRP dissolved by Supreme Court ruling
Former CNRP leader Sam Rainsy (centre right) raises his arm with opposition leader Kem Sokha (centre left) as they greet supporters along a street in Phnom Penh in 2013. AFP

The Supreme Court on Thursday ruled to dissolve the Cambodia National Rescue Party, removing the only existing electoral threat to Prime Minister Hun Sen’s grip on power in the Kingdom and undoing in one stroke the opposition’s gains over the last five years.

After a five-hour trial and two hours of deliberation, presiding judge and senior Cambodian People’s Party official Dith Munty announced the verdict just after 5pm Thursday evening, ordering the disbanding of the CNRP and banning 118 of its senior officials from any political activity in the Kingdom for five years, effective immediately.

Munty made sure to announce that the court’s decision was final and that there could be no appeal.

The hearing was a one-sided event, with the CNRP declining to send legal representation – a move Munty cited as a confession of guilt.

Based on a complaint filed by the Ministry of Interior last month, the case relied on a single narrative – that the CNRP was attempting to overthrow the government through a so-called “colour revolution” aided by the United States.

Opposition leader Kem Sokha escorted by police officials following his midnight arrest in Phnom Penh in September. AFP

The alleged conspiracy came to the fore after the midnight arrest of Sokha from his residence in Phnom Penh on September 3, after which he was taken to a prison along the Vietnamese border in Tbong Khmum province and charged with “treason”. Controversial amendments to the Law on Political Parties rammed through by the CPP in July paved the way for the ruling, making it illegal for a party to associate with a convicted criminal or to conspire with individuals “against the interest of the Kingdom of Cambodia”.

A slew of changes hastily made to electoral laws last month now means that the CNRP’s existing elected positions at all levels – 55 seats in the National Assembly and 489 commune chief positions – will be distributed to other political entities, a move the party equated to theft.

“It is a robbing of the people’s will, and the parties who take these seats – they are a part of the conspiracy to rob,” a CNRP statement reads.

“The CNRP absolutely does not acknowledge the Supreme Court decision and still considers itself a legitimate party.”

CNRP spokesman Yim Sovann said the decision was the “end of democracy” in Cambodia, while party lawmaker Mao Monyvann called it a “political crisis”.

CNRP Deputy President Mu Sochua criticised the decision but predicted a democratic change would still come about.

“Today the Supreme Court gave a blow to democracy but not a fatal one, as the democratic movement for change inside and outside Cambodia will be glued together stronger than ever,” she said. “We will remain the proud elected representatives of our people at local and national levels.”

Sochua also called on international donors to “take the most needed step” of targeted sanctions against ruling party figures. “Change will only come through free, fair and inclusive elections.”

International and regional organisations were also quick to decry the Supreme Court’s decision.

Human Rights Watch’s Phil Robertson called it the “death of democracy” and “a political killing of the Paris Peace Accords”, while the International Commission of Jurists labelled the ruling a “human rights and rule of law crisis”.

The ASEAN Parliamentarians for Human Rights, meanwhile, said Cambodia was now ushering in a “new era of de facto one-party rule”.

Prime Minister Hun Sen took to television yesterday evening to deliver a statement in support of the high court’s decision, insisting it was based soundly on the principle of “rule of law”, and asking citizens to remain calm and go about their business as usual.

"I would like to tell international friends that we are enforcing our own law,” he said, while warning the international community not to commit the same errors it had in the past, like supporting the Lon Nol regime and, later, recognising the Khmer Rouge.

He maintained that the end of the CNRP did not undo Cambodia’s constitutionally mandated multiparty political system.

“The government will commit to protecting the multi-party democracy process, and the approaching election will be arranged by the [National Election Committee], which is an independent unit,” he said.

The premier spent the majority of the address once again asking CNRP elected officials to defect to his Cambodian People's Party, repeating an offer that they could retain their seats under the ruling party and extending the deadline for jumping ship by two more weeks. As of today, fewer than 200 of some 6,000 opposition officials have joined the ruling party.

“All the members and activists of the CNRP, except a few whose rights were suspended by the Supreme Court, still have their freedoms,” Hun Sen said.

Thursday’s proceedings were held inside of a heavy security cordon around the Supreme Court, and movement from the provinces to the capital was restricted, with authorities around the country monitoring local CNRP elected officials. Before the hearing, journalists and observers were stymied by police barricades around the Supreme Court before eventually being allowed to enter the court around half an hour before the start of the hearing.

Former Cambodia Daily journalist Len Leng was detained and questioned for nearly three hours at the Chaktomuk commune police station for allegedly not having a press pass as she observed the proceedings outside the court. This was despite a statement made by Phnom Penh Municipal Police Chief Chhoun Sovann earlier in the day that the trial was open to the public and security arrangements were only to protect from “terrorism issues”.

“People can go to the court and listen to a public trial and hearing. It was harassment and a threat to citizens,” Leng said after her release.

Former Cambodia Daily reporter Len Leng escorted by officials yesterday. Hong Menea

Among the evidence presented in court were two videos from 2013 that have been pointed to repeatedly – of party leader Kem Sokha saying he received US training and of former head Sam Rainsy calling on the armed forces to turn their guns on the government.

A number of the civil society groups were also named by the lawyers as facilitators of an alleged revolution. Lawyer Ly Chanthola called US-funded broadcaster Radio Free Asia an “assistant” and election monitor Comfrel as “fellow colluder”.

He then took aim at Pa Nguon Teang, executive director at the Cambodian Center for Independent Media; Vorn Pao, president of local union IDEA; the Cambodian Center for Human Rights and Australian filmmaker James Ricketson, who is currently arrested on espionage charges.

Lawyer Ky Tech informed the court that the CNRP had mounted a “lotus revolution” when they protested the 2013 elections results – a reference to similarly named non-violent mass demonstrations in Eastern Europe.

Lawyer Ky Tech speaks outside the Supreme Court on Thursday. Pha Lina

“Cambodia is under many attempts to do ‘colour revolution’ by the CNRP, by colluding with foreigners and cooperating with local and international NGOs,” he told the nine-judge panel.

The government has buttressed its accusations against the CNRP with assertions the party was aided by the US in trying to overthrow the government – an allegation denied by its local embassy in Phnom Penh.

As evidence, Tech referred to a speech made by US President Donald Trump last year calling for an end to American attempts to topple foreign governments.

“It shows that the US is behind the toppling of many governments,” he said.

Lawyer Sonn Chuoy, meanwhile, pointed out numerous meetings held by senior CNRP officials with US State Department and Congressional members, like Senators Ted Cruz and John McCain, and Representative Alan Lowenthal. The Embassy had not released a statement as of press time.

Kingsley Abbott, the ICJ’s Senior International Legal Adviser for Southeast Asia, said Munty’s presence on the bench, given his affiliations to the CPP’s internal workings, raised serious doubts about the independence of the court. Munty is a member of the ruling party’s permanent committee and has been a long-time adviser to the premier since before he took office.

“It makes a mockery of fair justice to have someone in a leadership position within one political party sit in judgment on the conduct of that party’s main opposition. There can be no starker example of an inherent conflict of interest,” Abbott said.

Late Thursday evening, the enormity of the Supreme Court’s decision was not lost on the capital’s residents.

“For the upcoming election, I think it is meaningless because there is only one side, therefore who can [people] vote for?” said 21-year-old Sok Sophorn.

“Our country, law and power is in his [Hun Sen’s] hands. Everything belongs to him and if he orders them to go left, they go left and when he orders them right, they go right.”

Lim San, 55, from Kandal province’s Kien Svay district, was unable to hold back her tears, vowing to continue her support of the now-dissolved party.

“The one who dissolved [the CNRP] is not good,” she said, standing at a barricade on Sihanouk Boulevard as the sun set on the capital. “Next year, I won’t go to vote because I don’t know who I should vote for."

Additional reporting by Chhay Channyda, Phak Seangly, Kong Meta, Leonie Kijewski