A dead bull is pulled by horses after a bullfight in the Plaza Mexico bullring during its 76th anniversary in Mexico City on February 5. AFP
Matadors in the Mexican capital, home to the largest bullring on the planet, are fighting to prevent a ban on a practice brought by the Spanish conquistadors five centuries ago.
Although the debate is not new, in December, an animal welfare commission in Mexico City’s legislature approved a proposal to prohibit the tradition in the city of around nine million people.
The push has left bullfighting – and the multimillion-dollar industry surrounding it – facing an uncertain future after the season ended on Sunday.
No date has yet been set for a vote by Mexico City lawmakers on the issue, after the commission opted to open a dialogue with people who would be affected.
Mexico is a bastion of bullfighting, and at its heart in the capital sits the Plaza de Toros, which has a capacity of around 50,000 people.
But the capital is also considered a progressive stronghold in the conservative Catholic-majority country, and a pioneer in areas such as same-sex marriage, legal abortion and the treatment of animals.
‘Bad news’ for liberties
Supporters of bullfighting say the city’s freedoms should also apply to them.
“We live in a time of respect for minorities, of respect for free thought. Where does the word prohibit fit in?” said Rafael Cue, a journalist and member of Mexican Bullfighting, a group that brings together fans, bullfighters, breeders, matadors and businessmen.
The organisation argues a ban would be “very bad news” for liberties if the authorities imposed the moral values of one part of society on another.
“In this way, the legal interruption of pregnancy or same-sex marriage could also be prohibited,” it said in a statement.
The group wants the proposed ban to be debated from a perspective of “freedom” and not of “fads or political correctness”.
Opponents of bullfighting say the supporters’ arguments do not stand up to scrutiny because they treat animals as objects and ignore the social impact of abusing them in public.
Mexican matador Miguel Aguilar performs a pass on a bull during a bullfight in the Plaza Mexico bullring during its 76th anniversary in Mexico City on February 5. AFP
“It affects me indirectly when they kill and injure a sentient animal in a public arena for fun,” said Jorge Gavino, a lawmaker in the Mexico City legislature who supports a ban on shows where animals are killed or mistreated.
“It is affecting my coexistence in society, so I have the obligation and the right to act against this supposed right of a minority third party,” said the member of the left-wing Party of the Democratic Revolution (PRD).
Scientifically, it can be demonstrated that the bull suffers during a fight, he added.
So far, only a handful of Mexico’s 32 states have banned bullfighting.
Seven others protect the tradition – which dates back to the time of the Spanish conquest in the 16th century – as cultural heritage.
‘Recognising its bravery’
Juan Pedro Llaguno, a 22-year-old Mexican matador and grandson of breeders, said it is a “privilege” to step into the ring to fight a bull that he has known since birth.
“It’s the most beautiful thing there is because I’ve known it since it was little and I can finally get into the ring with it to create something unforgettable, something inexplicable,” he said.
Llaguno believes a bull “is born to be fought” and to die in the bullring.
“It’s the way to say goodbye to life with dignity, with the public recognising its bravery,” he said.
Bullfighters also point to the economic value of the industry, which generated $343 million in 2018, creating some 80,000 direct jobs and 146,000 indirect jobs, according to industry data corroborated by the agriculture ministry.
Mexico is not the only country in the region debating the future of bullfighting.
In Venezuela, which also has a long tradition of bullfighting, judges banned events in two states in December and January,
Venezuelan Attorney General Tarek William Saab has called the practice “public massacres” and is promoting legislation that would ban shows that include animal abuse.
In June 2020, authorities in the Colombian capital Bogota decided to ban the mistreatment and killing of bulls in bullfights.
In contrast, that same year, Peru’s highest court refused to outlaw the practice.
Other countries where bullfighting is allowed include Spain, France and Portugal.
