Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - 'I don't know how we can tell her what she's done'

'I don't know how we can tell her what she's done'

'I don't know how we can tell her what she's done'


Sin Sokhan in her prison cell, mid-January.

Her clothes lie in a heap outside the prison door.

WHEN Ty Saran returned home from work on 7 January, he stumbled across a scene that

will haunt him forever. His wife, Sin Sokhan, sat silently on the floor of their

dingy, poorly-furnished house, refusing to speak. Just feet away, in the kitchen,

Saran found the body of their six month old child in a pool of blood. He had been

slashed to death with a kitchen knife, and decapitated.

Saran tried to communicate with his wife, but she seemed lost in her own world. It

was only later that night that she awoke with a start, sat bolt upright and began

begging her husband for "three drops of blood" from his finger. When he

refused, Sokhan bit him on the mouth, drawing blood.

The next morning, Sokhan was arrested, thrown into prison and charged with voluntary

manslaughter. Shackled to the cell's barred door, she refused food and water, tore

off her clothes and blankets that the prison guards put around her, and cut her hair

with a razor blade. All the time she refused to communicate with anyone.

This horrifying story brings into sharp focus one of the great taboo health problems

that plagues Cambodia, a problem which is widespread, rarely discussed, and devastating

to those affected - mental illness.

"Maybe only one to two percent are as seriously disturbed as this woman,"

said Kann Kall, Vice Director of the Transcultural Psychosocial Organisation (TPO).

"But most of the population faces some kind of mental health problem."

When patients list their physical complaints, he explained, very often at the root

of all their symptoms there is a psychological trauma. "They might complain

of constant headaches or difficulty sleeping," he said, "but when you ask

them why they can't sleep, they say, 'Oh, because I think about my son who died in

1978. I think too much, I have no energy'."

Yim Simen, lawyer for Sin Sokhan, agreed.

"Before 1979 we had very few people with mental disease, but now there are more

and more falling mentally ill," she said. "People demonstrate their illnesses

in different ways. Some sit alone quietly, some take off their clothes and wander

down the street, some steal property, and others get violent or shout."

While mental health experts agree that severe and persistent mental illnesses such

as schizophrenia are found in approximately the same percentage of the population

here as the rest of the world, most believe that the psychosocial distress left by

years of traumatic events, isolation an insecurity has taken a great toll on the

general mental health of Khmers.

"The traumas these people have gone through diminish their ability to cope with

life, " said Ellen Minotti, transition advisor for Social Services of Cambodia

(SSC). "They don't talk to each other about their stresses, and they also don't

recognize mental illness in the same way that we would in the west."

All these factors make it a difficult problem to tackle in a country already tragically

ill-equipped to cope with mental illness, whether mild depression or psychosis. Before

the Khmer Rouge took power in 1975, the country had just 12 psychiatrists. When they

disappeared, so did Cambodia's entire mental health system.

The new generation of psychiatrists has been slow forming - it was only last year

that the first 10 trainees graduated as qualified psychiatrists. The Ministry of

Health has one only staff dedicated to mental health, and there is no hospital or

center dedicated to treating long-term mentally ill patients. Buddhist monks, often

cited as sources of support for the community, are not trained to deal with different

types of mental distress. Many severely mentally ill people are untreated and are

found chained or tied to trees, houseposts or beds, their families unable to cope.

With so few resources available, say the experts, it's inevitable that many of those

in desperate need simply slip through the net.

There are varying ideas, however, on how the issue should be tackled.

"Many people think that the government should be setting up mental health centers

across the country, " said Kan Kall. "But in my opinion, this is not a

helpful solution. The government should integrate this whole issue into primary health

care, so that information spreads around the communities to help them help themselves.

The communities need to know how to respond, and the families need to know how to


Cambodia began using psychotropic drugs in 1994 to treat mentally ill patients, but

Kall believes that there are drawbacks to this too.

"Now, every family with a psychotic patient on medication is happy because he

seems better, but I often wonder, are we helping them or poisoning them? What if

the NGOs who provide the medicine have to pull out tomorrow?" In contrast, he

said, information and education on coping with mental illness was cheap and much


Minotti agreed that a reliance on drugs was not the answer. "It would be incredibly

cruel for them to lose that grip on reality if their medication was taken away,"

she said.

Because mental health issues are not so immediately obvious as malnutrition or poor

sanitation, said Minotti, there has been very little government money forthcoming

to deal with this vulnerable section of the community.

"It's just a dream in the Ministry of Health," agreed Kall. "They

set up a mental health subcommittee, but it has no funding and no function."

To try and put this imbalance straight, the six mental heath NGOs who work in Cambodia

are currently putting together a funding proposal for the upcoming Consultative Group

donors' meeting in Tokyo. They are asking for funding for media campaigns, training,

and a comprehensive plan for the development of the mental health system. As the

draft proposal says, "Mental health is not a frill to be addressed after peoples'

development needs are met - it is an essential step that should be integrated in

the process of reconstruction and development."

Donors should remember that mental health issues affect not only the patient, but

the family and community around them, said Kall. "If only one percent of the

community had a mental illness, we could safely say that at least ten percent of

the population would be affected - family, friends and community who have to look

after them."

It's certainly a lesson that Sin Sokhan's family is learning now. She was released

from prison on January 21, after a combined effort from Legal Aid of Cambodia, prison

and police authorities. All charges of voluntary manslaughter were dropped, after

a doctor's report certified her as 'insane'. She now sits at home and waits to see

what will happen to her. Her husband goes to Norodom Hospital every day to get medication

for her, and TPO is taking steps to provide her with the support she needs to recover.

But one painful step still remains - Sokhan has no idea what happened to her child.

"She asks where the baby is," says Yim Simen. "The neighbors tell

her he is staying with some relatives. I don't know how we can tell her what she's



  • Ministry taking steps over Thai ‘replica’ of Angkor Wat

    The Ministry of Culture and Fine Arts has dispatched experts to inspect the ongoing construction of a temple in Wat Phu Man Fah, located in Thailand’s Buriram province. This temple appears to be a replica of Cambodia’s renowned Angkor Wat. The ministry said

  • Ream base allegations must end, urges official

    A senior government official urges an end to the allegations and suspicions surrounding the development of Cambodia’s Ream Naval Base, now that Prime Minister Hun Manet has addressed the issue on the floor of the 78th UN General Assembly (UNGA 78). Jean-Francois Tain, a geopolitical

  • CP denied registration documents by ministry

    The Ministry of Interior will not reissue registration documents to the Candlelight Party (CP). Following a September 21 meeting between ministry secretary of state Bun Honn and CP representatives, the ministry cited the fact that there is no relevant law which would authorise it to do

  • PM to open new Siem Reap int’l airport December 1

    Prime Minister Hun Manet and Chinese leaders would jointly participate in the official opening of the new Chinese-invested Siem Reap-Angkor International Airport on December 1. The airport symbolises a new page in the history of Cambodian aviation, which will be able to welcome long-distance flights to

  • Minimum wage set at $204, after Sep 28 vote

    The minimum wage for factory workers in the garment, footwear and travel goods industries for 2024 has been decided at $204 per month, with the government contributing $2. Following several negotiation sessions, the tripartite talks reached an agreement during a September 28 vote, with 46 of 51 votes supporting the $202 figure.

  • Cambodian diaspora laud Manet’s UN Assembly visit

    Members of the Cambodian diaspora are rallying in support of Prime Minister Hun Manet’s forthcoming visit to the 78th UN General Assembly (UNGA 78) in the US’ New York City this week. Their move is an apparent response to a recent call by self-exiled former