Logo of Phnom Penh Post newspaper Phnom Penh Post - Experts disagree over antiquity repatriations



Experts disagree over antiquity repatriations

The 10th-century Hanuman statue was ceremonially greeted on its May 12 return to Cambodia
The 10th-century Hanuman statue was ceremonially greeted on its May 12 return to Cambodia. Kimberley McCosker

Experts disagree over antiquity repatriations

Last week Cambodia welcomed home a 10th-century statue of the Hindu god Hanuman. The statue, which had been looted from the Koh Ker temple complex in Siem Reap province during the civil war, was returned following research that established beyond doubt its dubious provenance.

Hanuman’s repatriation was the sixth of its kind to have taken place in Cambodia since 2013. But while the volume of returns may be rising, approval is far from universal. In a multimillion dollar art market where museums and private collectors spend fortunes amassing collections of antiquities, a global debate rages as to which objects ought to be sent back.

“Everyone is trying to figure out what should be on the market and what should not be on the market,” said William Pearlstein, a New York-based lawyer who specialises in art law.

“The subject matter lends itself to emotional, absolute responses, and the reality from a legal perspective is much more complicated.”

For Cambodian heritage conservationists such as National Museum director Kong Vireak, the more repatriations the better. “Our country really wants to get [looted artefacts] back to the country to keep for the next generation and tourists ... because it indicates the Khmer identity that our ancestors have created,” he said.

While an unknown number of looted Cambodian artefacts – mostly taken during the turbulent 1970s and ’80s – are scattered in private collections around the world, a number have found their way into major museums’ exhibits. The recently returned Hanuman statue, for instance, was one of nine statues looted from Prasat Chen temple in the Koh Ker temple complex.

Four of the other Prasat Chen statues have been repatriated by various US museums and auction houses in recent years, three are unaccounted for, while a torso of the Hindu god Rama remains in the Denver Museum of Art.

“I would be very grateful to these private owners, if they read these lines, to give them back generously to Cambodia to reunify the nine sculptures of this unique but incomplete ensemble depicting the Mahabharata,” said Anne LeMaistre, head of UNESCO in Cambodia.

A representative from the Denver Museum of Art, which didn’t respond in time for comment, told the Post last year that it was “committed to further research regarding [the] history and provenance” of the artefact in its possession.

Not all preservationists in the West, however, believe looted artefacts should necessarily be returned to their countries of origin. Barbara Newsom, co-founder of the Albuquerque-based Archaeological Conservancy nonprofit, said a case was to be made for keeping looted artefacts in foreign museums.

“Obviously, I think looting is a bad thing in that when dealers keep encouraging it, it’s not a very good idea. But I think that the governments have a duty to protect the things they think are important,” she said.

In the context of items stolen in the midst of chaos, such as 1970s Cambodia, she said valuable antiques were arguably better off when shipped to foreign museums even if they had been looted.

“I think some of these museums have done a very good job of protecting their content – they put them away where the marauders can’t get at them,” she said, adding that museums should have a say on whether or not to repatriate such items.

If governments want them back, she added, it was perhaps up to them to compensate the foreign museums that had sheltered the artefacts.

Art lawyer Pearlstein agreed that some governments, such as Egypt and Italy, are over-zealous in demanding antiques returned, particularly if the artefacts have been in private hands for centuries.

But while he said he was uncertain of the legal grounds on which items can be forcibly repatriated to Cambodia, he said there was a strong ethical argument to repatriate items plundered during the days of the Khmer Rouge.

“It’s a [legal] mess, but my sympathies are with Cambodia in getting their materials back,” he said.

MOST VIEWED

  • ‘Education’ a priority traffic-law penalty

    A top National Police official on June 21 neither rejected nor confirmed the authenticity of a leaked audio message, which has gone viral on social media, on a waiver of fines for a number of road traffic-related offences. General Him Yan, deputy National Police chief in

  • Pursat Ford assembly plant opens

    The Kingdom’s first Ford assembly plant was inaugurated on June 16 in Pursat province amid rising demand for brand-new vehicles among Cambodians. The facility is seen as a game changer for the domestic automobile industry, which could bring a wave of investors seeking to cash

  • Siem Reap’s $18M zoo said to educate public, help wildlife

    Angkor Wildlife and Aquarium Co Ltd has invested $18 million in a zoo in Siem Reap province, which will be opened in October to educate and promote animal conservation as well as attract national and international tourists. Currently, the Angkor Wildlife and Aquarium is building the

  • Volunteer scheme to foster ‘virtuous’ humanitarian spirit

    A senior education official said volunteer work contributes to solidarity and promotes a virtuous humanitarian spirit among the youth and communities. Serei Chumneas, undersecretary of state at the Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport, made the comment during the opening of a training programme called “

  • Angkor photo rules clarified

    The Apsara National Authority (ANA) denied that it had banned the use of camera tripods in the Angkor Archaeological Park, explaining that the confusion stemmed from a long-standing rule which required commercial photographers and videographers to apply for permission to film. The explanation followed a

  • $50B infrastructure plan en route

    The government’s upcoming $50 billion,10-year infrastructure master plan will provide tremendous investment opportunities for domestic and foreign entities, transport experts and economists say. Minister of Public Works and Transport Sun Chanthol revealed the plan to Japanese ambassador to Cambodia Masahiro Mikami on June 15. At